Dynamics of habitat selection in birds : Adaptive response to nest predation depends on multiple factors / James H. Devries, Robert G. Clark, and Llwellyn M. Armstrong.

Includes bibliographical references (pages 316-318).

According to theory, habitat selection by organisms should reflect underlying habitat-specific fitness consequences and, in
birds, reproductive success has a strong impact on population growth in many species. Understanding processes affecting
habitat selection also is critically important for guiding conservation initiatives. Northern pintails (Anas acuta) are migratory,
temperate-nesting birds that breed in greatest concentrations in the prairies of North America and their population remains
below conservation goals. Habitat loss and changing land use practices may have decoupled formerly reliable fitness cues
with respect to nest habitat choices. We used data from 62 waterfowl nesting study sites across prairie Canada (1997–2009)
to examine nest survival, a primary fitness metric, at multiple scales, in combination with estimates of habitat selection (i.e.,
nests versus random points), to test for evidence of adaptive habitat choices. We used the same habitat covariates in both
analyses. Pintail nest survival varied with nest initiation date, nest habitat, pintail breeding pair density, landscape composition
and annual moisture. Selection of nesting habitat reflected patterns in nest survival in some cases, indicating adaptive
selection, but strength of habitat selection varied seasonally and depended on population density and landscape composition.
Adaptive selection was most evident late in the breeding season, at low breeding densities and in cropland-dominated
landscapes. Strikingly, at high breeding density, habitat choice appears to become maladaptive relative to nest predation. At
larger spatial scales, the relative availability of habitats with low versus high nest survival, and changing land use practices,
may limit the reproductive potential of pintails.